Descended in the Sumner family to General William H. Sumner (1780–1861), Boston, by 1861; possibly given to a great uncle of Charles F. Coleman, by 1861 [according to a letter from Charles F. Coleman, dated Oct. 14, 1937, original in curatorial object file, Arts of the Americas; Coleman notes that his grandfather’s brother was at one time employed by General William H. Sumner]; descended in the family to Charles F. Coleman (c. 1888–at least 1940), Newton, MA [according to letter from Charles F. Coleman, dated Oct. 14, 1937, original in curatorial object file, Arts of the Americas]; sold to George N. McMahon, by 1949; sold to Elizabeth R. Vaughan (born Tyson, 1871–1949), South Berwick, ME, and Sherborn, MA, by 1949 [according to note by George N. McMahon, original in curatorial object file, Arts of the Americas]; bequeathed to the Art Institute of Chicago, 1950.