Possibly private collection, London; sold Hôtel Drouot, Paris, February 27, 1882, La Collection de M. M. de Londres, either no. 71, Vierge avec gloire d’anges, for Fr 675, or no. 74, La Vierge et l’Enfant, for Fr 410 [the catalogue of the Dollfus sale stated that the painting was no. 72 in the 1882 sale, though that number is a Visitation]; Jean Dollfus, Paris; sold Galerie Georges Petit, Paris, pt. 3, April 1-2, 1912, no. 76, ill., to Kleinberger for Fr 15,600 [according to annotated catalogue at Getty Center, Los Angeles]; sold by Kleinberger to Ferdinand Hermann, New York [according to Hermann sale catalogue]; sold American Art Association, New York, January 15, 1918, no. 46, ill. to R. Ederheimer for $2,100 [price and buyer in annotated sale catalogue in Art Institute Library and American Art New 1918]. Private collection, New York, possibly that of Ederheimer; sold Anderson Galleries, New York, February 18, 1921, no. 107 to Kleinberger, New York [the consignor described as a “New York gentleman”, price and buyer in Kleinberger records, Department of European Paintings, The Metropolitan Museum of Art]; sold by Kleinberger to Martin A. Ryerson (died 1932), Chicago, 1922 [Kleinberger records cited above and invoice in curatorial file]; bequeathed to the Art Institute, 1933.