Estate of the artist [Lugt suppl. 838a]. Sold, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, February 22-27,1864, lot 636 or 637. (Emmanuel?) Pontremoli (died 1956) [according to Paris 1930]. Pierre Geismar, Paris [Lugt Suppl. 2078a]; sold, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, November 15, 1928, lot 11. Georges Aubry (died 1950), by June 1930 [Paris 1930]; sold, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, March 11, 1933, lot 40, to Lippmann [according to annotated sales catalogue]. Winslow Ames (died 1990), New London, Conn. [according to Joachim 1979]. Lt. Comdr. John S. Thatcher, Washington D.C., by October 1944 [New York 1944] Sold by Durlacher Brothers, New York, to the Art Institute, 1962.