Thomas Howard (1585-1646), second Earl of Arundel, in Padua after 1640 [according to Gutman sale, 1969, p. 38]; by descent to Henry Frederick Lord Maltravers [acc. to Christie’s, 1899, p. iv; for following chain of descent see Christie’s, 1899, pp i-v and title page]; descended to son, sixth Duke of Norfolk; passed as property of divorce to Dutchess Lady Mary Mordaunt, 1700, d. 1705; bequeathed to surviving husband, Sir John Germain, remarried 1718; bequeathed to second wife, Lady Elizabeth Berkeley, d. 1769; bequeathed to great niece Lady Mary Beauclerk, 1762 as wedding gift (m. Lord Charles Spencer, brother of third Duke of Marlborough; presumably passed to George Spencer, fourth Duke of Marlborough (d. 1817) [see Story-Maskelyne, 1870, p. 79]); David Bromilow, Bitteswell Hall, Lutterworth, England, by 1875 [acc. to Christie’s, 1899, title page]; bequeathed to daughter Mrs. Jary (Julia H. Mary) [sold London, Christie’s, June 1899, no. 477]. Henry Oppenheimer, b. Washington and later Frankfurt and then London (d. 1932) [sold London, Christie’s July 22-23,1936, no. 220]. Melvin Gutman, New York, by 1968; his sale, New York, Parke-Bernet, April 24, 1969, no. 73; Marilynn B. Alsdorf, Chicago [according to Wardropper 2000, p. 4]; given to the Art Institute, 1992.